Wednesday, January 27, 2016

Dave's Anatomy: My History As a Writer, #42: "The Silent Judge": A Tale of Jack the Ripper





I respond to calls for submissions a lot, especially ones that touch on an period of history I liked and about which I know something. I had written in response to a call for stories on Jack the Ripper, the notorious serial killer who terrorized London in the late 1800s. I knew a lot about that era from spending hours reading Victorian novels in graduate school:  Dickens, Thackeray, the Brontë sisters, George Eliot, and a whole parade of lesser lights. These gave me a feel for the era and the culture of the time. I thought I would try my hand, read up on Jack the Ripper, and sent the story off. Like so many stories, the publisher rejected it. But, like Winston Churchill, I never, never, never give up. I sent it out to a magazine called Alt Hist, which deals in variations on well-known historical incidents. The story made it into this journal.

Newspaper illustration of a murder victim of Jack the Ripper
Jack the Ripper is one of those perennially fascinating figures. Maybe he's so fascinating because we don't know who he was. There are endless speculations on the matter, and some fantastical candidates have been put forth in the attempt to identify him and solve the murder mysteries that have never been solved. My story, "The Silent Judge," attempts the same thing, though it carries no claim whatsoever of being true. It is entirely a fiction. But, when the Yiddish writer Isaac Bashevis Singer described village women crying when straw dolls were thrown into the raging river at harvest time, and speculating that once real live young women were the objects of this practice, he has one of the women muse, Was straw all that different from flesh? Is speculative and imaginative writing all that different from forensic investigation?

I don't know, but I like the story. A man who was a customer to Mary Jane Kelly, a prostitute and the last victim of the Ripper, finds out about her death. Like many Victorian men who consorted with "free women" (as prostitutes were euphemistically referred to) he is respectably married, in business, and the father of children. But Mary had held a place in his heart. When he reads of the brutality of the murder, he resolves to do something and begins his investigation.

He finds a young woman who shared a room (and a common occupation) with Mary and manages to track her down. She has a letter the killer wrote to the murdered woman. It gives some leads, though not many. He notes the angry down-slant of the handwriting, the educated vocabulary, and, most importantly, a location, Notting Hill—though it does not supply an address.

Using techniques he learned from reading Conan Doyle and Edgar Allan Poe's "The Purloined Letter," he begins to collect evidence. The same man who wrote the letter patronized whores, so he decides a brothel would be the best place to start looking. He finds one in Notting Hill that caters to high-class men and pays for one of its younger women.

Whore in the Killers video "Mr. Brightside"
I got the idea for the brothel from the video for "Mr. Brightside" by the Killers. The exotic girls sumptuously dressed and made up in sexy, exotic costumes inspired the high-class place the narrator goes to. He does business with several of the women there, returns one night and sees one is missing, asks, and is told the girl has been beaten. He finds her and she tells him about a man who comes every two of three months and beats and chokes her. She says that if he plans to kill the man, she will tell him no more. After he tells her about Mary and says the man will eventually kill her, his informant tells him all she knows: that the man lives in Saint David's, a section of London.

He finds the killer, trails him, and is puzzled that he visits Mary's grave. After analyzing other behavior, he realizes that Jack the Ripper wants to be caught. He wants to be identified so his deeds and name will be known forever. This, the narrator resolves, will never be.

He follows Jack into a sleazy, run-down section of London—the kind Dickens wrote about in Bleak House and Hard Times—and confronts him. The Ripper asks him if he is from the police. He says no and then this exchange takes place:
            Private investigator?”
            “A lover of Mary Jane Kelly,” I replied.
His smile faded. He looked fearful.
“Are you arresting me?”
I shook my head.
“No. I am going to kill you—right here and now. No one will ever find out who you are. You will not have the notoriety of which you have dreamed. No one will ever know your name.”

Several factory whistles go off and the narrator shoots, making certain he kills the man. He absconds and is never a suspect. The police cannot identify the body and assume it was a robbery and murder. The matter ends there.

The story is being written as the narrator near the end of his life. His wife has gone on. He has the satisfaction of having left a better world for his children, one in which the name of a brutal serial killer is not spoken. He writes of Jack the Ripper, "His name will ever be unknown. The name of Mary Jean Kelly lives on in peoples’ hearts and peoples’ sympathies."

The issue of Alt Hist featuring 
"The Silent Judge" is available in print
at this link.


For more titles see my Writer's Page

Read The Prophetess for some New Testament horror,
exorcism, and suspense.

No comments:

Post a Comment